Citi strategists worry about Nvidia financing, sectoral rotation and copper weakness
Citi says its 'generals' framework is about to flash red on Monday.
A stock-market signal employed by strategists at Citigroup is close to flashing red.
"To control for the fact that we may not be prescient enough to call the top, we have introduced the 'Generals' concept, which essentially suggests that it is a good risk management tool to take off equity risk whenever the bubble leadership breaks down," say global market strategists led by Dirk Willer, in a note to clients.
They define this as when four of the top seven stocks by market capitalization in the S&P 500 break below their 200-day moving average and stay for at least five days. By Monday, it's likely that this signal triggers, the strategists say.
Those four stocks are: Meta Platforms (META), Broadcom (AVGO), Alphabet (GOOGL) and Nvidia (NVDA).
"The generals work by removing downside tails, not necessarily by having a very high standalone hit ratio. But there are enough warning signs to our mind, to heed the signal here," the strategists say.
Front and center of Citi's concerns is the stock most in focus for the last fortnight: Nvidia (NVDA) . Willer and team note that 10% of Nvidia's revenues came from China and Hong Kong, and with export licenses there under review in wake of the Jensen Huang scandal, that is a risk.
The team also worries about the extent of Nvidia's financing exposure to the whole AI ecosystem. The company has a guarantee exposure of $118 billion, $10 billion up from the previous quarter, it has $32 billion of financial backstops to neocloud operators, $20 billion of future equity commitments and $74 billion of data-center leases. All of which makes some analysts decidedly queasy.
The Citi report identifies uncomfortable parallels between the current rotation among sectors and other periods of market duress in 2000 and late 2021. These bouts of volatility were characterized by an "aggressive change in leadership" where growth and momentum stocks lost favor compared to quality and value. In both instances, the S&P 500 SPX and Nasdaq NDX suffered major drawdowns. An aggressive shift from cyclicals into defensives also raises a yellow flag.
Huge factor rotation is a warning sign for SPX
"Overall," the report observes, "the price action under the hood is not overly reassuring."
Citi is also concerned about the message that copper-price weakness is transmitting. Copper (HG00) has long been interpreted by analysts as an indicator of overall economic growth and Citi eliminated its buy recommendation on the commodity at the end of October. The London price of copper has tumbled from a high of around $14,700 per metric ton to just $12,500 now. The relationship of copper to growth, as suggested by the Institute for Supply Management survey, suggests a downturn in the economic cycle is looming. A strong dollar is also detrimental to copper prices.
Bonds rally when copper falls
If the AI bubble does burst, the Citi team recommend investors turn to bonds, not just because of the direct contribution from the AI buildout but also a negative wealth effect.
"Now we are at 240% of GDP. A meaningful sell-off of a much larger market, may create more economic damage," say the strategists.
They concede the timing is not easy. In 2000, the Fed hiked once more after the Nasdaq 100 NDX peak was reached and the 2-year Treasury made a new high. Even longer-duration 10- BX:TMUBMUSD10Y and 30-year yields BX:TMUBMUSD30Y moved meaningfully higher.
-Jules Rimmer
