For a period of time on Thursday, it looked like the excitement over Anthropic's initial public offering would give artificial-intelligence stocks a much-awaited boost. But the trading action turned decidedly more mixed.
Shares of companies like Nvidia, Micron Technology and Broadcom that initially saw a broad-based AI rally on Thursday morning closed lower. Some of the AI stocks that closed in positive territory on Thursday, including Intel and Coherent, had their own specific catalysts.
Part of the issue may be that Anthropic's IPO prompted investors to shift around their holdings, according to Iskandar Rakhmatov, a portfolio manager at quantitative-strategy research platform Zeus Quanto.
"Investors who wanted the purest AI exposure got it today, and some of them sold Nvidia and other chip names to fund the new position," he told MarketWatch.
Granted, the excitement around Anthropic itself has also waned. Shares (ANT) opened 34% higher midday Thursday, but they pared those gains to close up 17% from their IPO price of $83.
Jack Amy, a quantitative-trading analyst at European digital wealth platform Moneyfarm, noted that at first, the Anthropic IPO "gave broader U.S. equities a lift, helping to steady nerves after a choppy week for tech."
"However, those wider gains have since pared back as macro concerns, specifically around tightening financial conditions and what that means for the capital-intensive AI trade, continue to weigh on sentiment," he added in emailed comments.
There are also renewed jitters about export policies after a report from a short seller discussed whether Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) chips have made it into Chinese servers.
"The claims misrepresent AMD's business practices and relationships. AMD complies with applicable US export control laws and regulations and maintains rigorous processes to ensure compliance across our global operations," an AMD spokesperson told MarketWatch.
"The China issues are likely to permeate across the semi industry as export controls are tightened," said Michael Casper, senior market strategist at wealth-management firm HB Wealth.
Investors have generally been worried that the U.S. government would take a tougher tack on sales of advanced technology to China in light of recent turmoil involving Nvidia.
Heading into Thursday's trading day, D.A. Davidson analyst Gil Luria told MarketWatch that Anthropic's IPO was "pivotal" for the AI investment cycle.
Luria said that a successful IPO could "extend the cycle by years," while an unsuccessful one could "stall investment" into the ecosystem.
Morningstar analyst Martin Szumski doubted the IPO would "fully turn around what has been very bearish sentiment lately." One reason is that investors saw Anthropic's prospectus weeks ago and knew "relatively what to expect."
The AI stocks that managed to hold onto some gains on Thursday had some idiosyncratic drivers. Shares of Coherent closed up 1% after the optical company announced a new buyback program, while shares of Intel closed up 2% following reports of remarks from a conference indicating that the company locked in an outside customer for its 18A manufacturing technology.
CoreWeave's stock, meanwhile, gave up a double-digit percentage gain and closed down 6%, despite a co-founder's disclosure that he purchased $30 million of the company's bruised bonds with the intention to hold them until maturity in 2031.
