Silicon Soap Opera: As Nvidia Stumbles, Are AMD & Broadcom Really Stealing The Crown?

🌟🌟🌟Wall Street is having a full blown identity crisis.  For years, the AI trade had one simple rule: buy $NVIDIA(NVDA)$  , close your eyes and count your money.  Lately that playbook has been torn to shreds.  As Nvidia continues its painful slide following CEO Jensen Huang's shock November 12 resignation and tightening US chip export rules, rivals $Advanced Micro Devices(AMD)$  and $Broadcom(AVGO)$  recently enjoyed sharp surges as traders scrambled for alternative AI plays.


Measurable Customer Shift or Merely Changed Expectations?

Right now, the dramatic split between NVIDIA and its challengers is primarily a shift in investor expectations rather than an overnight exodus of customers.


No Immediate Order Surge:

Analysts point out that while AMD and Broadcom rallied on Nvidia's leadership turmoil, there is no confirmed evidence yet that hyperscalers have suddenly cancelled Nvidia orders in favour of rivals.


The Key Person Discount:

Nvidia has just delivered a huge Q3 results and projected roughly USD 130 billion in Q4 revenue, proving AI demand has not evaporated.  However, losing a visionary founder who personally coordinated everything from product roadmaps to cloud financing introduces massive execution risks.


A Hedge Against Chaos:

Investors are not abandoning AI.  They are simply hedging.  Money managers are rotating out of NVIDIA's drama and into AMD and Broadcom on the bet that cloud giants will eventually diversify their supply chains.  It turns out that even in silicon, nobody likes paying top dollar for chips.


Why Is The Broader US Market Down Today?

If you looked at your portfolio on Thursday November 19 and winced, you are not alone.  The S&P500 dropped 2.02% for its 6th straight loss.  The Dow plunged over 1,100 points.  Even AMD and Broadcom could not escape the gravity, pulling back in Thursday's session alongside the broader tech sector.  

This is due to 3 major pressures:

"Sell the News" on $Anthropic(ANT)$ IPO:

AI lab, Anthropic made a historic Nasdaq debut, surging 34% at the opening bell before paring gains.  Rather than lifting all boats, the event triggered a wave of profit taking across expensive AI hardware stocks.


Hawkish Federal Reserve Jitters:

Recent comments from Fed officials signalling potential interest rate hikes to combat sticky inflation, together with 10 year Treasury yields hovering above 5%, have sucked the oxygen out of high multiple growth stocks.


Geopolitical & Short Seller Headwinds:

New US Commerce Department export restrictions aimed at closing overseas data center loopholes, combined with a high profile short report targeting AMD's China exposure, have poured cold water on the chip rally.


Wall Street's Verdict: Price Targets for AMD & Broadcom:

Across 32 covering analysts on Google Finance, 91% rate AMD as a Strong Buy with zero Sell.  AMD carries an average consensus price target of USD 651.18, an upside potential of 33.32%.

Broadcom commands a 94% Buy rating across 31 covering analysts, with zero Sell rating.  Broadcom has an average consensus target of USD 514.86, an upside potential of 48.52%.


Are AMD and Broadcom Good Buys Against This Backdrop?

Buying into a 6 day market losing streak takes a strong stomach and both stocks come with clear trade offs in this environment:


The Bull Case:

Both AMD and Broadcom are posting phenomenal fundamental growth: 

AMD's data center revenue recently surged 97% year over year, while Broadcom's AI semiconductor revenue jumped 221%.

Thursday's broader market pullback offers a cheaper entry point than earlier in the week.  Any real customer diversification away from a transitional Nvidia provides a massive upside.


The Bear Case (Risks):

Neither stock is immune to macro gravity.  AMD trades at a lofty trailing P/E ratio over 106 and faces immediate scrutiny over Chinese export loopholes.

Broadcom, while more reasonably valued at 44x earnings, has seen a few analysts trim near term price targets amid fears that if NVIDIA slows down its ecosystem spending, the entire AI tide could recede.

In stark contrast, NVIDIA trades at a forward P/E ratio of just 10.1x.  This sits at about one third of AMD's Forward P/E of 30.4x and about half of Broadcom's Forward P/E of 19.4x, placing Nvidia at its lowest forward valuation multiple in over a decade.


Bottom Line:

If you have a multi year time horizon, Broadcom offers a steadier, customer silicon moat.  AMD offers higher beta torque if it captures the GPU market share.

However in a market currently punishing high valuations and reacting negatively to 5%+ Treasury yields, it is much better to dollar cost average rather than going all in on a single day.


Concluding Thoughts 

The semiconductor throne is currently wobbly, not empty.  While NVIDIA sorts out its sudden succession drama, AMD and Broadcom have proven that they are no longer just sidekicks.  They are legitimate contenders ready to catch whatever business that falls off the table for NVIDIA.

Just remember: When the broader market is throwing a rate hike tantrum and digesting mega IPOs, even the best chipmakers get caught in the crossfire.

Keep your eyes on actual customer order flows, have a sense of humour and don't let daily ticker whiplash dictate a long term strategy.

As Warren Buffett famously put it:

"The rearview mirror is always clearer than the windshield".

While Wall Street sees substantial upside ahead for both AMD and Broadcom, long term returns will ultimately depend on whether future earnings live up to today's lofty forecasts.


@Tiger_comments  @TigerStars  @Tiger_SG  

# Nvidia Falls Another 3.30%: How to Choose After AMD's Slide?

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Report

Comment(16οΌ‰

  • Top
  • Latest
  • ZOE011
    Β·11-20 10:53
    TOP
    Order growth alone wouldn't prove Nvidia lost customers. Are hyperscaler disclosures separating fresh AI spending from business shifted between suppliers?
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • koolgal:Β 
      When a company like $NVIDIA(NVDA)$ dropped a huge USD 115.8 billion quarter & casually projected USD 130 billion for the next one, it sends a strong message that its fundamentals are rock solid!
      11-20 18:34
      Reply
      Report
    • koolgal:Β 
      Although in this Nvidia's case, you could argue the drama is in the details.
      11-20 18:31
      Reply
      Report
    • koolgal:Β 
      The devil is in the details.
      11-20 18:31
      Reply
      Report
    View more 4 comments
  • 1PC
    Β·11-20 22:08
    Reply
    Report
  • ELI_59
    Β·11-20 23:33

    Great article, would you like to share it?

    Reply
    Report
  • CHINNY168
    Β·11-20 19:23

    Great article, would you like to share it?

    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • koolgal:Β 
      Best of luck πŸ€πŸ€πŸ€
      11-20 19:42
      Reply
      Report
    • koolgal:Β 
      May you have a winning week πŸŒˆπŸŒˆπŸŒˆπŸ’°πŸ’°πŸ’°
      11-20 19:42
      Reply
      Report
    • koolgal:Β 
      Happy Trading πŸŒˆπŸŒˆπŸŒˆπŸ’°πŸ’°πŸ’°
      11-20 19:42
      Reply
      Report
    View more 2 comments